Starred review from July 15, 2021
A lively investigation of the numerous connections among fascism, imagery, media, and politics. Books about fascism are rarely unpredictable, and social science nonfiction is rarely a wild thrill ride. But when Nathan applies the style and imagination he demonstrated in his debut novel, Some Hell (2018), that's what we get. Though the author is upfront about his lack of expertise with the mechanics of fascism and photographs, his originality of thought drives this impressive nonfiction debut. He leans on Susan Sontag and Bertrand Russell to make some points early on, but it's the way he weaves together the deaths of Matthew Shepard, the Columbine High School massacre, and 9/11 with the rise of Donald Trump and Survivor that makes readers wonder what twist is coming next. "If Marilyn Manson played America's antichrist, Trump seems to be it--the American monster par excellence," Nathan writes. Not all his pronouncements hold up intellectually, as he sometimes exaggerates to make a convenient point--e.g., "the American fascist aesthetic is one of noise and merchandise...the aesthetic of resistance is no different--equally noisy and commodified, right down to the T-shirts, the slogans, and stupid tweets." Nonetheless, readers will be fascinated as the author explains the importance of expressing ourselves visually through the origin of memes, the language of GIFs, and how it all fits together with the work of Homer and the power of representation. Nathan delivers deep thinking and clever turns of phrase in equally abundant amounts, making his history lesson and philosophical discussion a page-turning good time. Of course, the shadow of Trump looms large: "While the most visible aspect of this fascism is, without a doubt, an omnipresent, autocratic bigot whose every photograph and tweet and facial gesture is consumed and interpreted in myriad ways--a kind of image-meth scarcely anyone can stop using--to call Donald Trump this fascism's alpha and omega is to give him too much credit." An unexpectedly entertaining scholarly warning about fascism's spread through imagery.
COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.